Solutions for Assignment #16 (Chapter S3)

1.) In Einstein's theory of general relativity, the notion of gravity is obsolete.
So, how does he explain the acceleration that we have gotten accustomed to
attributing to gravity (for example, an apple falling from a tree)? Please explain
in 50 words or more.
Einstein would say that the Earth's mass distorts spacetime. It makes a "dip" in spacetime,
so spacetime near the Earth is not flat, it is curved. The moon is trying to take the shortest
(translated as straightest) route through spacetime. If you use non-relativistic thinking (i.e. if you
consider 3 dimensional space, rather than 4 dimensional spacetime) that route looks like a circle
about the Earth. As for the apple, when it was still attached to the tree, the Earth's rotation
carried it along. Then, it's stem detached from the tree and the apple was free to follow
its own path. In the curved 4 dimensional spacetime, the path carries the apple to the Earth's surface.

2.) See figure S3.19 in the textbook (it is the same as one of the figures on the Chapter S3
webpage -- look in the section on Gravitational lensing and click the "diagram" link).
If you were talking with a friend who already believed that spacetime is curved
near massive objects but who had never heard of gravitational lensing, how would
you explain gravitational lensing (using this figure) to your friend (in 100 words or more).
I would tell my friend that both light and objects respond to curved spacetime. Light travels
in the straightest possible path (between 2 places) in a curved spacetime. In the figure, the light is coming
from the real object, the blue ball at the top, center of the figure. The object emits light in all
directions. Two of those directions are shown on the figure -- they are traced with yellow lines.
As the photons travel along these paths, they come somewhat near to a very massive object.
The massive object is drawn in orange. It has caused spacetime to curve. So, when the photons
from the "real object" (marked with the blue dot) come near the "massive object"
(marked with the orange dot), they continue to travel in the straightest possible path,
but from our point of view, that path seems to be curved. The paths seem to bend, such that
the left path bends back toward the right after passing the massive object and vice verse for the other path.
Neither of these paths come to the Earth straight-on -- both come to the Earth slightly from the side.
So, when we detect the photons, we detect them coming from the side. The figure shows two sets
of dashed lines, these lines represent the perceived paths of the photons. By that, I mean that
our eyes don't realize that spacetime is curved, so when we unconsciously trace back the photon's paths,
we assume that the photons made straight paths through a flat space. So our eyes perceive
the sources of the photons as being "image 1" on the left of the "real object" and "image 2"
on the right of the real object.

3.) According to Einstein's Equivalence Principle, if you were in a windowless space capsule and you felt weightless,
a.) You could be floating freely, far from any massive objects
b.) You could be in free-fall, falling into a massive object
c.) Both of the above
d.) None of the above
Answer: c

4.) Imagine a flat spacetime diagram in which distance east is plotted on the x axis and time is plotted on the y axis. If someone is stationary, how would his/her "worldline" look on the spacetime diagram?
a.) His/her "worldline" would be straight and horizontal
b.) His/her "worldline" would be straight and vertical
c.) His/her "worldline" would curve to the right
d.) His/her "worldline" would curve to the left
Answer: b

5.) Imagine two sections of spacetime; the first is perfectly flat and the second is curved. Also imagine that there is an object in the flat section and that the object's path is a straight line between two points. If there were also an equivalent object in the curved section of spacetime, what sort of path in the curved section of spacetime would be most equivalent to the straight path in the flat section of spacetime?
a.) The shortest possible path between 2 points on the curved section of spacetime
b.) A straight line that intersects the surface of the curved section of spacetime
c.) A single point on a curved section of spacetime
d.) None of the above is remotely equivalent to the straight path in flat spacetime
Answer: a

6.) According to Einstein, being in free fall around a massive object is equivalent to
a.) Following the shortest path between two points in curved spacetime
b.) Traveling at a constant velocity far from any massive objects
c.) Both of the above
d.) None of the above
Answer: c

7.) According to Einstein, if an object does not follow the straightest possible path as it travels between 2 points in spacetime, it
a.) "feels weighty"
b.) could be accelerating
c.) could be being held up against the force of gravity
d.) All of the above
e.) None of the above
Answer: d

8.) Einstein's theories say that the curvature of spacetime causes
a.) What we perceive as gravity
b.) What we perceive as time
c.) What we perceive as energy
d.) None of the above
Answer: a

9.) Suppose that you and your friend, Jackie, are in a spacecraft. The spacecraft is accelerating (in the forward direction). You are at the front end of the spacecraft; Jackie is at the back end.
a.) Both you and Jackie would perceive time to move at the same rate
b.) You think that time runs faster for you and Jackie also thinks that time runs faster for you
c.) You think that time runs slower for Jackie and Jackie thinks that time runs slower for you
d.) None of the above
Answer: b

10.) Suppose that you and your friend, Jackie, are in a spacecraft. Your spacecraft is standing in its launch pad on Earth. You are at the front end of the spacecraft (further from the Earth's surface); Jackie is at the back end (closer to the Earth's surface).
a.) Both you and Jackie would perceive time to move at the same rate
b.) You think that time runs faster for you and Jackie also thinks that time runs faster for you
c.) You think that time runs slower for Jackie and Jackie thinks that time runs slower for you
d.) None of the above
Answer: b